Hello dear
Welcome to DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus
DiCarlo's Pizza - Columbus brings a slice of Wheeling, WV, to Ohio, delighting locals with its unique pizza style. Located at 15 E 2nd Ave, this beloved eatery offers a menu filled with tantalizing options like cheesy bread, handmade pizza rolls, and crispy pizza trays. The standout feature here is the distinctive preparation: the crust and sauce are baked first, topped with cold provolone and pepperoni, creating a texture that’s both crispy and chewy. Customers rave about the fresh ingredients and exceptional service, making it a must-try for pizza enthusiasts eager to explore authentic Ohio Valley flavors.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
CHEESY BREAD
PIZZA ROLL
WATER
TRAY
About
DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus
Welcome to DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus, a beloved slice of the Ohio Valley made famous for its unique take on the classic pizza. Located at 15 E 2nd Ave in Columbus, this eatery has carved out a niche for itself with a distinct style of pizza that many might find unfamiliar yet utterly delightful. If you're seeking a pizza experience that strays from the ordinary, you've stumbled upon a gem.
What sets DiCarlo’s apart is its signature approach. The pizza boasts a crispy, crunchy crust that is baked to perfection. Unlike conventional pizzas, the cheese is added cold, resulting in a remarkable texture that keeps the cheese slightly firm and enhances the flavor profile of every bite. The handmade pizza rolls, loaded with provolone cheese and your choice of toppings, offer a delightful twist that you won't find at your average pizzeria.
Customers rave about DiCarlo's offerings. Michael So's review encapsulates the essence of what makes this pizza style special. He describes it as a fusion of rich flavors, where the minimally cooked pepperoni and barely melted cheese create a captivating experience. Melissa Fielding echoes similar sentiments, emphasizing the harmonious blend of crust and sauce, expertly baked together before toppings are added. For lovers of unique culinary experiences, this is a must-visit.
Moreover, the service here is poised and efficient, making it a perfect stop for those on-the-go. The clean and welcoming atmosphere is ideal for picking up your favorite pizza or pizza roll to enjoy at home. Whether you’re ordering a tray of 24 slices or an enticing take-and-bake pizza kit, rest assured, each bite at DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus promises to be a celebration of flavors that lingers in your memory long after you've finished your meal.
In conclusion, DiCarlo’s Pizza - Columbus not only offers a unique and tasty twist on traditional pizza but also brings the beloved Ohio Valley pizza culture to life in a way that captivates both locals and newcomers. Don’t miss out on this culinary delight; your taste buds will thank you!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Amazing pizza in a style most people, not from the Wheeling, WV/Eastern Ohio area, have never seen. Have an open mind when trying it for the first time. The cheese is barely melted and the pepperoni is not cooked. I know, sounds weird but trust me the crust and sauce are simply amazing. Chances are, you will be hooked. I was unaware of this 15 years ago when I was staying at a hotel near Wheeling. I was upset since the pepperoni wasn't cooked and I don't think I even tried it. I assumed they messed up my order and forgot to add the pepperoni before cooking. My mistake. A buddy clued me in and ever since then it is a must eat when traveling East. Thank heavens we can get this locally now. The service being to go only was great so the atmosphere was fine, it's a to go pizza shop. Not needlesly Five Star but clean and nice. Try this if you haven't. You have been missing out. ”
“ Delicious crispy, crunchy, cheesy perfection! The best pizza in the world! Hands down! The Kings & Queens of Real Pizza! ”
“ Best pizza ever. Anyone who says its not doesnt know pizza. The crust and sauce are baked together and then when it comes out the cold cheese and pepperoni is added. It does melt some. But its ohio valley style pizza. Dont let the negative nancies sway you. ”
“ One unique pizza in Columbus. Really liked their crusty and fresh-baked pizza with sprinkled cheese. Service was excellent too. ”
“ Just like I remember it!!! I glad it’s here in Columbus now. I’m from the Steubenville-Wintersville area and grew up with this type of pizza. ”
“ Compared to the DiCarlos Pizza in Wheeling, I give this location an A. The crust was crispy, the sauce sweet and of course the shredded cheese and pepperoni is awesome! ”
“ This pizza is STANDOUT good. Was apprehensive due to the unconventional style, but it blew me away. Love that they offer a 6 slice box. Perfect amount of pizza for 2-3 people. Italian ice was also superb. ”
“ Delicious crunchy crispy perfection! Absolutely the best pizza in Ohio! Always made with fresh ingredients by the sweetest, and most kind owners/workers ever! Is a pleasure talking with Anna, Nick and Newton each visit! Newton is a very hard working boy. ”